Sell or Pawn Your Silver at All Island Jewelry & Loan


All Island Jewelry & Loan will pay top dollar for your sterling silver. We are one of Long Island’s leading buyers of sterling silver flatware and hollow ware. We do not melt your sterling. Each piece is evaluated for both its weight and its artistic value. As soon as our analysis is completed, you will receive an immediate cash offer for your pieces.

Items must be stamped “Sterling” .925 – .900 – .800. Many items stamped Sterling are weighted with plaster (i.e. candlesticks) and must be broken to get the true weight. Knives which have sterling handles are figured at 1/3 – 1/2 oz. each.


All Island Jewelry & Loan also buys diamonds, gold, coins and currency, watches, jewelry, and other collectibles. Whether you are looking to sell your valuables or to obtain a pawn loan, we pay top dollar and pride ourselves on a solid reputation of integrity. Just bring your items to our store in Centereach, Long Island, New York and our experienced staff will give you an estimate of the value of your unwanted gold or jewelry.

Here is a quick summary of our most popular selling and pawn loan categories:


Diamonds can be very valuable depending on some characteristics the diamonds may have. The shape, cut, color, clarity, and carat weight all play an important role in the overall value of your diamond. Learn more.


GOLD is usually stamped 10K, 14K, 18K. Gold is bought by the pennyweight (dwt). There are 18.2 dwt to the avoir oz. or 20 to the troy oz. Dental gold must be yellow and is usually around 16k. Items stamped 1/20 12k – H.G.E. are gold plated and worth very little.  We test all gold, marked and unmarked.  If there are diamonds or other precious stones in the item brought in, we will add their value to the weight of the gold.  Learn more.

Coins and Currency

All Island Jewelry & Loan deals in all types of U.S. and Foreign Coins. U.S. 90% silver coins are dimes, quarters, or halves dated 1964 or older. U.S. 40% clad coins are halves only dated 1965-1969. War Nickels are dated 1942 – 1945 with large mint marks only. Silver dollars were minted up to 1935. We buy all early U.S. & foreign coins and paper monies, but coins that are damaged in any way are almost unsaleable, but may have scrap value. The better condition the higher the price. We pay top dollar on all gold and silver coins.


Many common gold watches made in the last 20 to 30 years are probably worth their weight in gold only, but All Island Jewelry & Loan will examine the watch to determine if it has any value above melt. Hunting case watches (flip Covers) that are working or repairable are valuable. Repeater watches which chime the time are very valuable – often worth over $1,000. Old silver watches are also worth a premium. Particularly valuable watches are Rolex; Cartier; Tiffany; Omega; Patek; Phillipe; Piaget.

If you have something not listed here, bring it to our store in Centereach, Long Island, New York and let us tell you what the value is for your item.

Certain brands & origins can bring larger premiums on silver:

– Black Starr & Frost
– Cartier
– Dominick & Haff
– Gorham
– S.Kirk & Son
– Stieff
– Tiffany & Co.
– Wallace
– Whiting
– English Silver
– Chinese Silver
– French Silver
– German Silver
– Japanese Silver
– Norwegian Silver
– Persian Silver
– Russian Silver